Ask
many Americans today about the
Tuskegee Airmen and they will tell you that they were a group of Negro
airmen who proved their critics wrong and became "one of the best"
fighter groups to fight in World War II. (The term "African-American" did not come into use until the late 1960s.) Such an
assertion is
half-right; the men who were part of the 332nd Fighter Group and the
99th Fighter Squadron were Negro airmen - at least most of them
were.They were all colored but at least one was evidently of Indian
ancestory since his name was Singh. (American Indians, Asians and
Hispanics were not considered "colored" and served in
regular units.) As to whether
or not they
proved their critics wrong is open to debate, but there is nothing to
prove the assertion that they became one of the best fighter groups to
fight in the war. In fact, the general consensus of the senior
officers under whom they served was that they were the least-effective
in the theater rather than the best. Another oft-quoted remark is the assertion that
the men of the 332nd were "so good that they never lost a bomber,"
which is simply untrue. That at least some of the young colored
airmen who won their wings at the Army Flying School at Tuskegee,
Alabama became competent airmen is a fact, but their record in combat
is hardly spectacular.|
Who was Yancy Williams?
According to numerous Internet articles and information read into the Congressional Record, President Franklin Roosevelt ordered the Air Corps to initiate US Army pilot training for Negro pilots one day after a Howard University student named Yancy Williams filed suit after having been turned down for Army pilot training. While such a suit was filed by the NAACP on behalf of a Yancy Williams in early 1941, Roosevelt had actually announced that the Army would begin training Negro pilots four months previously in October 1940 a few days before the presidential election in a political move to attract Negro votes. Williams' suit was actually filed exactly one day before the War Department announced that the 99th Pursuit Squadron had been constituted. There was a Yancy Williams in Class 44 J-E, which graduated on December 28, 1944 almost three years after the first Tuskegee pilot training class graduated. He is reported as having graduated with the rank of first lieutenant, which would indicate that he was already an officer when he began training. Accounts relate that Major Yancy Williams flew reconnaissance flights under President Dwight Eisenhower. However, a Major Yancy Williams was killed in the crash of an F-86D in 1952 before Eisenhower took office in January, 1953. |
To
command its first colored squadron, the Army selected Captain
Benjamin O. Davis Jr., a West Point graduate and the son of a career
Army
officer who had grown up in the military. (Contrary to popular belief, Davis was not one of the first Negro cadets to attend West Point.) Davis' father was the Army's first Negro general officer. He
became a
member of the President's Advisory Committee on Negro Troop
Policies when it was established in August, 1942. At 29 years of age,
Captain
Davis was
actually past
the maximum age for Army flight training but requirements were waived
for him
to become part of the program. Davis initially failed the flight
physical, but was admitted to the program anyway due to the need for an
officer with his qualifications. He was the only commissioned officer
in the class of thirteen men who began training at Tuskegee in October,
1941. Eight cadets washed out but Davis
and four cadets completed the program and were awarded the silver wings
of US Army pilots in March 1942; the cadets recieved commissions as second lieutenants. The new officers were
immediately assigned to the 99th
Pursuit to train as fighter pilots while Davis was assigned to the base
staff. Lt. George "Spanky" Roberts, who had been a member of the first class, was placed in
command of the squadron on June 1. When the men entered flight
training
the nation was still at peace and Army plans were only for one
squadron, but war broke out in December and created a need for
more
pilots and aviation personnel so the War Department
expanded its plans. Instead of one colored squadron, as the nation
mobilized for war the Army decided to establish four colored
pursuit squadrons, to organize an all-colored pursuit group and to also
establish a
medium bomber group made up entirely of colored personnel. (Some
sources have
said that plans also included a colored troop carrier group but no
mention of such a plan is made in Army publications or in most of the
information available about the colored airmen. There were
recommendations to commission Negro civilian pilots as service pilots
to serve in the Air Transport Command in Liberia but as far as is
known, no Negroes served as service pilots although some colored
civilian
pilots became liasion pilots assigned to colored infantry and artillery
units.)
The
99th's new assignment was with the Twelfth Air Force XII Air Support
Command, commanded by Major General Edwin J. House, which was part of
the Northwest Africa Tactical Air Force that had been
organized to provide sir support for Allied ground combat units.
Equipped
with fighter/bombers, light and medium bombers, Northwest Africa Air
Support
Command was one of three combat commands reporting to Lt. General Carl
Spaatz, who was doing double duty as commander of Twelfth Air Force and
the Northwest Africa Air Forces, a joint American and British
organization. Northwest Africa Air Support Command was commanded by Air
Marshall Coningham while House served as deputy and also as commander
of XII Air Support Command. Spaatz was also the senior American air
officer
on General Dwight Eisenhower's
staff. In January a joint Allied air organization had been formed as
Northwest Africa Air Forces with Spaatz in command. The North African
campaign had just
ended and Eisenhower was preparing for the first invasion of the
European continent,
which was scheduled to take place in July in Sicily. The 99th was badly
needed
for air operations in preparation for the invasion. But before the
squadron could enter combat, it had to go through an indoctrination
period with the Northwest Africa Training Command at Casablanca, a
training program that lasted approximately a month.
(Several
articles and books about the Tuskegee Airmen have claimed that the
squadron received inadequate training but the claims are not true; the
99th received as much training as other new fighter
squadrons assigned to North Africa and far more than the squadrons that
arrived with the invasion forces more than six months before.) Shortly after the squadron arrived in Casablanca the 99th recieved its
full complement of brand new P-40s, and began training under the
supervision of experienced fighter pilots in XII Training Command, one of whom was Major Philip
Cochran who had served as a squadron commander in the 33rd Fighter
Group, and who would later gain fame as commander of the 1st Air
Commando
Group in Burma. Cochran would report that the 99th pilots were
good at
formation flying but that their navigational skills were lacking. Some
Tuskegee authors have claimed that he also said the 99th pilots were
"natural dive-bombers" but if this is true, he was referring to
non-combat training conditions.
Cochran
was only with the 99th during their theater indoctrination training and
was not with them in combat as he rotated back to the US about the time
that the colored airmen began operations. In early
June, their training completed, the squadron moved to Tunisia where it
was attached to the veteran 33rd Fighter Group, commanded by Colonel
William W. Momyer. | Some authors in writing about
the
Tuskegee Airmen have
disparaged Momyer, claiming that he had been reckless in early
operations because he took his group too close to German lines. In
reality, Momyer's 33rd Group gave up 25 of it's replacement P-40s to a
new French fighter squadron which organized as the Lafayette
Escadrille and was left short of airplanes. In January, 1943, less than
two months after the US
landings at Casablanca, XII Support Command moved Momyer's 33rd Fighter Group into a
forward field at Thelepte in central Tunisa, which placed the group in
a position to better support the advancing Allied forces and to reduce
fighter range for missions escorting bombers. A 33rd squadron, the 58th
Fighter Squadron, began operations from Thelepte in early
December immediately after the field was captured under the command of
Maj. Cochran - their operations so close to the lines were referred to
as "guerrilla air warfare." The rest of the group joined them in early January. The group was soon
recognized as the most valuable fighter group in the region. A shortage
of fighters developed in North Africa, particularly P-40s. While P-38s
could be brought down from England, P-40s had to be brought from the
US. Because it was engaged in heavy combat, Momyer's 33rd Group
suffered heavy losses, both combat and operational, losses that could not be replaced. Contrary to
assertions, it was not the only group operating that far forward. There
were two squadrons of P-39s, two squadrons of DB-7 and A-20 light
bombers and the French Lafayette Escadrille all operating from the
advanced field at Thelepte where they were under constant attack by German aircraft. By
February 2 the 33rd was down to only thirteen operational P-40s. On
February 6 Momyer's group was relieved by the 31st Fighter Group, which
flew Spitfires, and moved back to Algeria to rest and re-equip. After
re-equipping, the 33rd
returned to combat a month later and continued adding to its record. The group was
credited with the destruction of 34 enemy airplanes in one week. Momyer
was
actually one of the Army's most thought-of young officers. In October,
1943 he returned to the United States and was assigned to the Army Air
Forces Board
where he became responsible for developing fighter/bomber tactics. In
the
US Air Force that came into existence in 1947, he served as a fighter
commander and in the Pentagon, where he was the project officer for the
development of Lockheed's C-130 Hercules. In 1966 as a lieutenant
general he was sent to Saigon to command Seventh Air Force, a role he
filled until 1968. After his return to the US, he was given command of
the Air Force's Tactical Air Command and promoted to four stars. He was
a no-nonsense officer who
was more than willing to accept casualties when the need arose and
expected his men to be aggressive, but he was far from reckless. As the
senior USAF officer in Southeast Asia, his goal was to support the
ground forces but he was not willing to place his pilots and aircrews in
extreme danger to attack targets with little military value. Because of the negative report he wrote on the 99th Fighter Squadron, Momyer is implied to have been racist as some officers, particularly some from the South, were. Actually, although he had spent his childhood in Oklahoma, Momyer spent his teen years and went to college in the Northwest, in Seattle, Washington. Accusations of racism directed at Momyer come from officers (Colonels Chuck Yeager and Harry "Heinie" Aderholt) who ran afoul of him while subordinate to him in Southeast Asia and resurrected the rumors about his experience with the 99th in order to divert attention from their own issues. |
In
June the 332nd began flying escort missions. For the first few weeks
they flew P-47s, but in early July the group equipped with P-51s. A
popular myth arose
and has been accepted as fact
that the 332nd pilots "were so good that they never lost a bomber" but
it is just that, a myth. In
reality, they lost at least 25 bombers that were under their protection
if attributing bomber losses to the
fighter groups that escorted them is fair. Nowhere in Army Air Forces
records are bomber losses attributed to any specific fighter group; the
332nd claim was made years after the war by certain authors of articles
and books about the unique fighter group. Impetus for the claim
evidently came from an article that appeared during the war
claiming the group hadn't lost any bombers in 100 missions. (The
claim
was no doubt true when placed in proper context - there was a period of
about six months in which
332nd pilots encountered few enemy aircraft and in which few bombers
were lost to fighters. They had, however, lost a
number of bombers that were under their escort during their first few
months of operations when enemy opposition was still strong and would
lose more when German fighter activity picked up during the final
months of the war.) The group's first escort
mission was to
Munich on June 9 and there were losses among the bombers. Group pilots
claimed five German fighters but two bombers were lost. The June 25 mission was notable in that a
flight strafed an enemy vessel and reported a sinking. The young
pilots, who had only been in the theater since March and whose
combat experience was minimal, reported that the ship was
a destroyer but there is considerable controversy over the attack as no
German destroyers were reported lost that day. It possibly was a former
Italian
gunboat that ran aground while being strafed. That the young pilots
misidentified the ship and possibly claimed a ship that was not sunk is
no reflection on their competence - it was quite common for airmen to
misidentify ships while dozens, perhaps hundreds, of claims of ships
being sunk were made that were not supported by examination of German
(and Japanese) records after the war. On June 30 five bombers
were reported lost on a mission on which the 332nd flew escort, but
it's believed that the group had already left the formation before
the
attack occurred. On July 8 an estimated 15-20 German fighters attacked
the bomber formations and shot down two B-24s. The Red Tails did not
shoot down a single enemy fighter. Four days later on July 12
the Red Tails were credited with four enemy fighters, but three bombers
were lost. On July 18 the Red Tails had their best day, at least in
terms of the number of enemy aircraft claimed, but in terms of bomber
losses it was also their worst and was also one of the worst days for Fifteenth Air Force bombers. Group pilots were
credited with twelve enemy planes shot down, but the cost was high. Three
Red Tail fighters were lost and FIFTEEN B-17s
went down to fighter
attack during the battle! Two days later 332nd pilots claimed four more
fighters but two
bombers were lost to fighters. By this time the 332nd had equipped with North
American P-51 Mustangs and the 99th FS had joined the group at its
base at Ramitelli. The group had proved to be an effective
fighter group, but it was not the highly qualified group that Tuskegee
Airmen fans claim, a group so good that the bomber groups requested it
as escort and that "never lost a bomber." The 332nd had actually "lost"
more than twenty bombers to enemy fighter attack during it's first two months of escort
operations. (In fact, bomber groups
had no say in which fighter groups were assigned to escort duty.
Furthermore, the ratio of bomber to fighter groups in Fifteenth Air
Force was more than two to one.) Bomber losses declined after that, but it was hardly due to the
effectiveness of the 332nd as an escort group.
August 1944 saw a general overall decline in bomber losses to fighter attack that continued for the rest of the war.
In fact, for the remainder of the war, encounters with enemy aircraft became fewer and further
between. The mission record for the 332nd reveals
that of the 311 missions the group flew, group pilots only encountered enemy
aircraft on
31 (10%) of them. From October 11 to March 16 only one 332nd pilot was
credited with an enemy aircraft - and from December 9, 1944 to March
14, 1945 group pilots DID NOT EVEN SEE A SINGLE ENEMY PLANE!!! It was
only during the final few weeks of the war that 332nd pilots once again
encountered German fighters. There is an explanation for this. Shortly
after the 332nd entered the escort role, Soviet troops overran the oil
fields at Ploesti, Romania and the supply of gasoline to the Luftwaffe
became severely restricted. Little fuel was available for training and
the operational squadrons hoarded what fuel they had and only sent
their
fighters up when particular targets were threatened. Those targets
were mostly around the Berlin area which was well north of Fifteenth
Air Force's area of operations in northern Italy, the
Balkans and southern Germany. Northern Germany - including Berlin
- was Eighth Air Force's responsibility. Furthermore, the 332nd was evidently not
fully
integrated into Fifteenth Air Force fighter operations. Fifteenth
included two fighter wings, the 305th and 306th, which were
combined into XV Fighter Command late in the war. The 305th Fighter
Wing was made up of three groups that flew Lockheed P-38s and the 306th
initially included three groups equipped with P-47s until it was joined
by the 332nd Fighter Group. By July 1944 the 306th wing was equipped
exclusively with North American P-51 Mustangs. Commanded by Brigadier
General Dean Strother, who had previously served in the Pacific, the
306th included a fourth group - the 332nd - made up of four squadrons
instead of the
standard three squadrons normally assigned to a fighter group.| In reality, the other pilots WERE out to get kills, because the change in tactics was devoted to destroying the Luftwaffe and that was what they were there for. In his New Years message to Army air units in Europe, General Arnold had stated that "we are out to destroy the Luftwaffe, in the air, on the ground and in the factories." The new tactics were designed to destroy as many German fighters as possible, both on the ground and in the air. Instead of sticking close to the bombers to protect them and allow the Germans to make their attacks and then get away unmolested, the new strategy was for the fighter groups to make maximum use of the superiority of their aircraft and knock as many fighters down as possible and to destroy as many as possible on the ground. Instead of staying in close proximity to the bombers, the fighter pilots were expected to pursue and destroy them in the air, and after they had reached the point where fuel supplies dictated it was time to return to base, they were to go down on the deck and strafe enemy airfields. Of the seven fighter groups assigned to XV Fighter Command, the 332nd had the lowest score of enemy aircraft destroyed of any for the time period in which they were involved in combat. Some 332nd veterans claim that they were told by bomber crews that they liked to have them around because the German fighters would leave them alone when they were there. This is also possibly true, but it wasn't because the 332nd pilots were "so good." With only four squadrons, the group was never able to mount more than about 50 fighters. XV Fighter Command only had seven fighter groups, including the 332nd, which were hardly enough to cover all of the bomber groups on a mission. If German pilots observed the presence of fighters, they were more likely to go looking for bombers where there were none. Because of the way they were being used, if bomber crews observed US fighters before they reached their target area, they were most likely to be Red Tails because the 332nd was the only group that was assigned to"stay close to the bombers". Bomber losses declined after the 332nd was assigned to escort duty, but the decline was because the other six groups were ranging ahead of the bombers and shooting down the assembling Luftwaffe fighters before they ever came in sight of the bomber stream and the escorting 332nd fighters. |
Staffing
problems plagued the medium bomber group and delayed the unit's
activation for many months beyond the projected operational date. The
washout rate among the colored aviation pilot cadets was high,
running higher than 50% at times. Until the 332nd reached it's
full
complement of pilots, most of the graduates of the program were
destined either for it or as replacements for the 99th Fighter
Squadron, which was overseas for more than two years. Since the B-25
was a multiengine
airplane, pilots had to undergo additional training to qualify to fly
them while experienced single-engine pilots had to be retrained. Two
pilots were
assigned to each crew, which increased the demand for pilots. Each B-25
crew also initially included a navigator and a bombardier, although
these two skills were eventually combined. Enlisted crew chiefs,
engineers and
gunners also had to be trained. Until early 1944 when the
Army decided to proceed with plans for a colored bomber group, there
were no colored navigators. Men who had washed out of the pilot
training program were offered the opportunity to train as navigators
and most accepted and qualified with little difficulty.
Navigator training was not at Tuskegee, but at Hondo, Texas.
Originally, the 477th was assigned to Selfridge
Field, an airfield near Detroit, Michigan which had also served as the
home base for the 332nd Fighter Group before it's deployment to Italy.
But by 1944 racial problems had increased dramatically within and
outside of the military, and much of the unrest seemed to be centered
on Detroit,
which had a large Negro population and was also a center for the labor
movement, in which there was considerable unrest and agitation by union
leaders. Fearful that racial unrest in the city would spill over into
the bomber group, the Army decided to transfer the 477th south
to Godman Field, the airfield at Ft. Knox near Louisville, Kentucky.
Poor winter weather conditions in Michigan were given as a reason for
the
transfer.| Several authors have maintained that the "success" of the 332nd Fighter Group paved the way for integration of blacks in the military. Such a point is difficult to prove since the 332nd operated as a completely segregated unit. In fact, the record of the 99th Fighter Squadron before it became part of the 332nd illustrates that Negroes peformed better when working as an intact unit in company with other units. The 332nd was not the only US Army colored unit to serve in combat, although it is undoubtedly the best known and the glamour of aviation enhanced it's status. Dozens of colored quartermaster battalions were organized and gave excellent performance as cargo handlers and truck drivers, particularly in the RED BALL EXPRESS trucks in Europe. Two colored infantry divisions saw combat, one in Europe and one in the Pacific, and both had poor records, although their poor performance is attributed to racism on the part of their white officers and a resulting lack of leadership. A few colored battalions such as the 761st Tank Battalion saw combat. During the final months of the war in Europe when all divisions had been committed and the replacement pools had dwindled, General Eisenhower authorized the assignment of black NCO's and soldiers from rear units to line duty with white combat units. In most cases the new combat soldiers fought well and it was their experience that demonstrated that blacks and whites could fight alongside each other. |